How to Review a Journal Article: 13 Steps (with Pictures)

Toggle navigation. Articles in Press Current Issue. Journal Archive. Volume 6 Issue 4. The concept of "review article" is separate from the concept of peer-reviewed literature. It is possible for a review article itself to be peer-reviewed or non-peer-reviewed.

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. For daily newspaper, see Las Vegas Review-Journal. If by using the first two methods you were unable to identify if a journal and an article therein is peer-reviewed, you may then need to examine the journal physically or look at additional pages of the journal online to determine if it is peer-reviewed.

This method is not always successful with resources available only online. Locate the masthead of the publication.

Q. How do I write a journal article review using APA format?

This oftentimes consists of a box towards either the front or the end of the periodical, and contains publication information such as the editors of the journal, the publisher, the place of publication, the subscription cost and similar information.

Does the journal say that it is peer-reviewed? If not, move on to step d. Online Submission.

How To Write an Article Review

Learn more. For more detail, Click here. Hard Copy of the Journal is vailable online. Carefully referenced : References should be selected to give a balanced view of the field. More comprehensive reviews may also be acceptable and will be assessed on a case by case basis by the Editorial board. Please complete a Review proposal form and submit it via our online submission system if you are interested in writing a Review.

To aid the editorial board to judge the suitability of a proposed review for the journal, all authors should complete a review proposal form. The aim is not to provide an extra burden for the author, but to ensure the article will appeal to the journal's intended readership and to reduce the overall time and work needed in the preparation of the final manuscript.

Acceptance of the proposal by the editorial board does not guarantee publication of the final manuscript. Review proposal forms should be submitted review journal article our online submission system.

For accepted proposals or invited submissions, authors are encouraged to submit their full manuscript on the Royal Society of Chemistry article template, which is available to download here. Please contact webmaster rsc. Authors should present their work as objectively as possible. Arguments that discriminate people by race, sex, origin, religion, etc are not accepted.

Bogus results must not be given. Reviewers should not take advantages from the manuscript; instead, they should help the authors to improve their work.

Journal article review

Unlike typical research articles, review articles do not present any original primary research. For this reason, some assignments may not allow you to directly cite a review article in your paper. However, you can still use the article to get a general understanding of the field and to find important primary research articles. Also note that for most senior theses in the sciences, the proper place to cite a review article is in the first few paragraphs of your introduction. By placing references to a review article in your early intro, you give your reader a place to go for more information if they are unfamiliar with your field.

Finding a review article is relatively simple, though it varies slightly depending on what database you are using.Related wikiHows. About This Article. Co-Authored By:. Co-authors: 8.

Review journal article

Updated: October 30, Deutsch: Einen Zeitschriftenartikel rezensieren. Italiano: Scrivere una Recensione di un Articolo Accademico. Thanks to all authors for creating a page that has been read 72, times. Reader Success Stories.

AA Azeez A. Oct 29, A Anonymous Jun 30, I have never done one before, and this information was very helpful in completing my assignment. Very instructional, and I liked the examples. Thank you. LD Laura Drawls Aug 26, I took the drink water option, ate loads of fruit, and chewed gum. It worked for me. Experiments including patient or animal data should properly be documented.

Consider the article from your own perspective. Your review will help the editor decide whether or not to publish the article.

What is a scholarly literature review? How can I find one? - LibAnswers

It will also aid the author and allow them to improve their manuscript. Giving your overall opinion and general review journal article of the article is essential. Your comments should be courteous and constructive, and should not include any ad hominem remarks or personal details including your name unless the journal you are invited to review for employs open peer review.

Providing insight into any deficiencies is important. You should explain and support your judgement so that both editors and authors are able to fully understand the reasoning behind your comments. You should indicate whether your comments are your own opinion or are reflected by the data and evidence.

The journal for which you are reviewing might have a specific format e. View the checklist here. This review is to summarize the essence of the article, its key arguments, and findings, and the author's attitude towards the subject-matter. You also assess the new knowledge that the author has brought to the discipline and its application potential.

Writing an article review is not just about expressing your opinion on the work. It is a fully-fledged evaluation of the author's ideas expressed in the article. As you analyze the article, you use your own ideas and research experience.

Journal article review format

Your overall conclusions about the article base off on your own judgment backed up by your experience in this field and your common sense. You only talk about the research already performed by the article's author. You do not perform any new research yourself. You should know exactly how you will be writing your article review before you even read the article in question. This is because you should know which points of the article are most important to your review in advance.

The article review outline usually goes like this:. Read the introduction, the conclusion, the first sentences of each paragraph.

Then read several opening paragraphs. Only then you should read the whole article. This first reading is only for getting the overall idea of the point that the author sought to make with this article. Carefully read the article several more times. If you are reading it from a screen, use a highlighter for the most meaningful parts.

If you are using a print version, use a pen. The most meaningful parts here are the main points and the facts to support them. Instead, make notes on the margins and draw connections between different parts of the article. It is best to do it in written form, such as an outline or a piece of free writing. In addition, there should be no surprises here: The measures should be clearly matched to the research questions or the hypotheses.

Are their choices of methods adequate to find out what they want to find review article journal in this study? Would other methods provide a substantial improvement; if so, would employing these methods be feasible or practical? Do they provide some justification for the methods they have chosen?

Does this appear to be adequate? Reviewers might consider four questions here: Does the results section tell a story--taking the reader from the research questions posed earlier to their answers in the data? Is the logic journal review articles Are the tables and figures clear and succinct? Can they be "read" easily for major findings by themselves, or should there be additional information provided?

Are the authors' tables consistent with the format of currently accepted norms regarding data presentation? Do the authors present too many tables or figures in the form of undigested findings? Are all of them necessary in order to tell the story of this research inquiry; or can some be combined?

Remember that tables and figures are very expensive from the standpoint of the journal and that undigested data obscure rather than advance the cumulative development of knowledge in a field. Are the results presented both statistically and substantively meaningful? Have the authors stayed within the bounds of the results their data will support? Outside of the education system, experts often review the work of their peers for clarity, originality, and contribution to the discipline of study.

When answering the questions of what is an article review and how to write one, you must understand the depth of analysis and evaluation that your instructor is seeking. That is a type of professional paper writing which demands a high level of in-depth analysis and a well-structured presentation of arguments.

It is a critical, constructive evaluation of literature in a particular field through summary, classification, analysis, and comparison. If you write a scientific review, you have to use database searches to portray the research. The analysis, review journal article, and comparison require use theories, ideas, and research, relevant to the subject area of the article. Much like all other reviews, a journal article review evaluates strengths and weaknesses of a media stereotypes essay. It differs from a journal article review by the way that it evaluates the research method used and holds that information in retrospect to analysis and critique.

Scientific article review involves anything in the realm of science. Often, scientific publications include more information on the background that you can use to analyze the publication more comprehensively. The format of the article should always adhere to the citation style required by your professor. When you know the answers to these questions, you may start writing your assignment. Articles appear most commonly in academic journals, newspapers, and websites. If you write an article review in the APA formatyou will need to write bibliographical entries for the sources you use:.

Web : Author [last name], A. Can you point me in a direction to figure out how to write an APA format journal article review? Toggle menu visibility. Ask Another Question. Answered By: Alan Aldrich.

Logiciel de recrutement et de multidiffusion


 MULTIDIFFUSER rapidement toutes vos opportunités d'emploi sur les jobboards et les réseaux sociaux 


 DISPOSER d’un espace emploi en ligne pour tous vos recrutements : CDI, CDD, Intérim, Stage, Freelance, ...


 ACCELERER vos recrutements avec un outil simple et performant


 CONSTITUER une CVthèque interne mutualisée illimitée


Formulaire de contact